『Evolutionary Analogies: Is the Process of Scientific Change Analogous to the Organic Change?』

Barbara Gabriella Renzi and Giulio Napolitano

(2011年11月刊行, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, xvi+137 pp., ISBN:9781443833547 [hbk] → 版元ページ

【目次】
List of Figures and Tables ix
Preface xi
Acknowledgments xv


CHAPTER ONE: EVOLUTIONARY ANALOGY 1

1.1 Natural Selection 1
1.2 Evolutionary Epistemologies 4
1.3 Metaphor 8
 Some history
 Metaphor as a cognitive structure
 How do metaphors work?
 Type Hierarchies


CHAPTER TWO: EVOLUTIONARY ANALOGIES 21

2.1 Kuhn 21
 Scientific development
 Progress from: the evolutionary analogy in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
 Local and global progress
 RSS: adaptation and niches
 Ecological niches, localities and adaptation in evolutionary biology
 Kuhn’s confusions
2.2 Campbell 39
 Knowledge gain and the blind-variation-and-selective-retention
 mechanism
 How blind is knowledge gain?
 Campbell’s intention
2.3 Toulmin 52
 Explanation or metaphor?
 Darwinian rationality
 Environment
 Ontological adequacy


CHAPTER THREE: A TYPE HIERARCHY FOR SELECTION PROCESSES 65

3.1 Type Hierarchies 66
 Top-down or bottom-up?
3.2 Existing generalisations 67
 Hull
 Hull is not general enough
 Darden and Cain
 Darden and Cain are too general
3.3 Type hierarchy of selection processes 72
 A provisional hierarchy
 Mechanical Selection
 Evolution
 The complete Type Hierarchy
 Intentionality and Artificial Selection
 Cyber Selection
 Drift
 Immune system
3.4 The usual objections 82
 Variation
 Progress
3.5 The evaluative step 86
 A brief note on ontological and pragmatic approaches
3.6 Conclusion 91


CHAPTER FOUR: SCIENCE AS A SPECIAL CASE OF SOCIOCULTURAL ENTITY 93

4.1 Direction and convergence in science 93
 Replication
 Interaction
 Identity by descent
 Convergent realism
4.2 Natural Selection and Sociocultural Selection 112
 Science as a special case of sociocultural entity
 The Orthogenetic Hypothesis
 The Orthogenetic Analogy
4.3 Orthogenesis and scientific change 115


CONCLUSION 121


REFERENCES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY 123
INDEX 135